English / Compare And Contrast Essay-Stereotypes

Compare And Contrast Essay-Stereotypes

This essay Compare And Contrast Essay-Stereotypes is available for you on Essays24.com! Search Term Papers, College Essay Examples and Free Essays on Essays24.com - full papers database.

Autor:  anton  01 January 2011
Tags:  Compare,  Contrast,  stereotypes
Words: 964   |   Pages: 4
Views: 498

Stereotypes are a conventional, formulaic, and oversimplified conception, or opinion, that can create tough misconceptions of certain people, which many times turn out harsh and hurtful. In “Black Men in Public Space”, by Brent Staples, and in “What is a Homosexual?” by Andrew Sullivan, the authors talk about different stereotypes and the causes of them on individuals. These two essays have plenty similarities in the way that they express themselves but the main idea of each essay is different.

In “Black Men in Public Space” and also in “What is a Homosexual?” each author talks about how they are excluded and sometimes misjudged just for being different. The main dissimilarity between these essays is that Brent Staples talks about how people classify him as being a mugger or a rapist, just for being black and walking in the streets at night, but in “What is a Homosexual?” Sullivan mainly talks about his personal experience and reflection of what is it like to be a homosexual man and feel excluded many times just for this very reason.

However, both authors use similar ways and techniques to express themselves, such as using personal anecdotes. On “Black Men in Public Space”, the author starts off the essay with a personal experience, “My first victim was a woman – white, well dressed, probably in her early twenties.” Then, Staples goes on talking about how the woman casts back “a worried glance” (Staples 229), and “picked up her pace and was soon running in earnest.” (Staples 230) The author also explains that the woman only did this because “to her, the youngish black man – a broad six feet two inches with a beard and billowing hair, both hands shoved into the pockets of a bulky military jacket – seemed menacingly close.” (Staples 230) We see that Andrew Sullivan also uses several anecdotes in his work, for example when he is talking about his experience in high school: “I was fifteen and getting changed in the locker room for the first time again with a guy I had long had a crush on.” (Sullivan 165). He goes on explaining how he “became literally breathless, overcome by the proximity of my desire” because the boy “took off his shirt, and unknowingly, slowly, erotically stripped.” (Sullivan 165) The authors use anecdotes in their essays to show the reader how they feel and try to put them in their position, reminding them of what they are – either gay or black.

Both writers also are able to explain what they learned from their experiences. For example at the end of his essay, Staples explains how “Over the years, I learned to smother the rage I felt at so often being taken for a criminal… I would take precautions to make myself less threatening. I move about with care, particularly late in the evening. I give a wide berth to nervous people on subway platforms during the wee hours, particularly when I have exchanged business clothes for jeans.” (Staples 231) He also explains more desperate measures; such as whistling melodies of the most popular classic composers, as well as other actions. Sullivan also explains to the reader what his experiences have taught him, “The gay teenager learns in that kind of event a form of control and sublimation, of deception and self contempt, that never leaves his consciousness. He learns that that which would most give him meaning is most likely to destroy him in the eyes of others; that the condition of his friendships is the subjugation of himself.” (Sullivan 165)

A detail that both authors also take in consideration is their ability to express to the reader how they felt each time they were being judged. A quote in “Black Men in Public Space” explains how the author felt “surprised, embarrassed, and dismayed all at once” (Staples 230), while Sullivan declares that “No homosexual child, surrounded overwhelmingly by heterosexuals will feel at home in his sexual and emotional world, even in the most tolerant of cultures. And every homosexual child will learn the rituals of deceit, impersonation, and appearance.” (Sullivan 166) After reading this part of the author’s essay, the reader feels compassionate and concerned, as well as empathetic towards a community who is excluded just for being different.

However, Sullivan’s essay talks more extensively about the generated problems in a gay boy’s adolescence, and all the troubles that they might go through. He also talks about the good of adolescents in society, how they are “undoubtedly a more highly developed sense of form, of style” (Sullivan 169). But ends his essay explaining how life for homosexuals will always be unjust and the conflict doesn’t cease to exist, as long as they are the great minority.

Nevertheless, Staples writes his essay with a more positive and reflexive note. He ends by stating how he gets over the fact that people will always put stereotypes on people, and even though it still bothers him he will simply try his best to ignore it and also lower the bad ideas of people. He also writes his essay with a more personal point of view than Sullivan, since he only talks about his experience and doesn’t explain thoroughly how other blacks might feel when dealing with the same problem.

Weighing up the evidence, the reader can feel the differences and similarities of each of the author’s personal way of writing, and also notice the different techniques they use to convey to the reader their point and try to make them understand and feel empathetic towards them. Both of these essays, even though they talk about different communities, have one final and same point – anyone who is stereotyped or is different in any way will have different experiences, and also learn many things from them.



Get Better Grades Today

Join Essays24.com and get instant access to over 60,000+ Papers and Essays

closeLogin
Please enter your username and password
Username:
Password:
Forgot your password?