Music and Movies / Movie Report: Extreme Measures

Movie Report: Extreme Measures

This essay Movie Report: Extreme Measures is available for you on! Search Term Papers, College Essay Examples and Free Essays on - full papers database.

Autor:  anton  30 October 2010
Tags:  Report,  Extreme,  Measures
Words: 898   |   Pages: 4
Views: 348

This film “Extreme Measures” enables us, the viewers, to regard another side in medical issues today; in which humans are being treated as lab rats against their own will, in the name of science. It talks about a young British doctor named Dr. Guy Luthar, who is at the beginning of a great long term career with the Gramercy hospital in New York. The movie begins with two homeless men running for their lives from some unknown entity, one of which ends up at Gramercy hospital under the treatment of Dr. Guy Luthar. We manage to find out three aspects about him, before he dies in a horrific manner, one of which is his name, Claude Minkins, and that the man who had saved his life was called Teddy Dolsen (who was the other man we saw at the start of the movie running for his life). Dr Luthar also finds silver wrist bands, which are used in hospitals; therefore, he was being treated at a hospital before he ended up at Gramency. We also hear him tell Dr Luthan that he was at “Triphase”. Dr. Luthan was unable to find out the reason why Claude had died , thus he decides to send Claude’s body for inspection, in hope to find out what had really taken place, but later finds out that all of Claude’s records had disappeared into thin air along with Claude’s body. This leads Dr. luthan to begin investigating on his own, during this time period Dr. Luthan is being constantly trailed by two officers who manage to break into his home and frame him; as a result, Dr. Luthan looses his job. We the audience understand that another doctor in Dr. Guy Luthans field is the founder of “Triphase” which happens to be an organization that carries tests on homeless men but for an unrevealed cause. Unaware of the dangers awaiting him Dr. Luthar continues investigating the case of Clause Minkins even if it did cost him his entire career. Dr. Luthan manages to find out from one of his homeless patients that underground lays a whole other habitat where only the homeless live in. There, Dr. Luthan manages to find out himself that the homeless are used as lab rats against their own will. Dr. Luthan also finds Teddy Dolsen there but in a Horrible shape wearing a silver wrist band as well. Finally Dr. Luthan manages to gain the trust of the people, and they allow him to take Teddy with him to gramercy, unfortunately the men who have been following Dr. Luthan kill Teddy along with other homeless people. Searching for help, Dr. Luthan goes to a colleague of his, a nurse, who eventually turns out to be working with “Triphase”. Dr. Luthan finds out the secret behind this sick organization. “Triphase” was established by Dr. Mirek, his purpose was to find a way to grow nerve cells to cure paralyzed humans. The reason he chose humans as specimens was that each species has its own genetic code, and the reason that he chose homeless people was that he thought that just because they are homeless they will not be “missed” or needed. This organization is eventually shut down; in addition, Dr. Mirek had a genuinely good cause but tried to achieve it in the worst possible manner, which was testing on humans against their wills and knowledge.

During this film we see many tackled principles having to do with medical ethics, which are justice, non maleficence, beneficence, and autonomy. At the beginning of the movie, before the plot is even introduced, we manage to see Dr. Luthan go against both principle of Beneficence and justice. During his shift, we see Dr. Luthan having to go through an ethical dilemma where he is placed in a position having to choose between treating two patients. One of which is a criminal, who was in a highly critical state, and another patient who is a police man, who was in a less critical state. Dr. Luthan chose the police man even thought he was less in need of his assistance; here he favored one patient over another because of his occupation (justice and beneficence). In medicine such boundaries do not exist, every patient is equal to the other patient; and, every doctor must try his best to treat as many patients in need, starting with the most critical patient. As we begin to be introduced to the plot we see that Dr. Mirek goes against the principle of autonomy and non maleficence. He was treating patients against their consent, and also forced them to go against their reasoned judgment (autonomy). He also was using humans as test specimens where he operated on them against their wills; and, they were also in no need of his treatment. Dr. Mirek held very risky experiments where he was removing samples of ones spinal chord which costs someone his life let alone having to go through great pain (non maleficence).

Personally I did not enjoy the movie but I liked the message that it was trying to convey. It showed us how it is to be like in the place of test specimens but, after all animals are not humans…. In conclusion, this film sets a great example of how technology interferes in negative ways concerning medical ethics today.

Get Better Grades Today

Join and get instant access to over 60,000+ Papers and Essays

Please enter your username and password
Forgot your password?