Music and Movies / Philosophy Of Competition

Philosophy Of Competition

This essay Philosophy Of Competition is available for you on! Search Term Papers, College Essay Examples and Free Essays on - full papers database.

Autor:  anton  28 October 2010
Tags:  Philosophy,  Competition
Words: 541   |   Pages: 3
Views: 638

The views of competition are very wide spread. It seems that everyone has something to say on the subject. Those people who are in favor of competition often point out that it is a strong motivator, it offers more public exposure and can gain community support as their reasoning. Those who have the opposite view often point out that the self esteem is often damaged in those who do not receive top ratings, the pressure to win is always present, and it encourages non musical goals which will be mentioned in more detail later.

The struggle has been long and is still continuing on placing music education as a curricular subject. The intrinsic values of the arts and especially those in music are often pointed out in making this justification. Despite this, the extrinsic motivation of competition is still used in many schools today. These examples can be seen in chair placement and contests. Extrinsic values of the area of music have been used to gain the necessary support for a group and that will probably not change. The problem arises when these values become the primary reason for existing. When it reaches this point the art of music is dead.

In the indoor setting, competition has changed throughout its history. Sight reading was implemented to insure that fundamentals were being taught and that bands were not just practicing concert pieces all year. When it comes to competition in marching bands or other extracurricular bands, the achievements seem to be a little more extrinsically based.

Children are naturally competitive and this allows for the world that we live in to become more and more dependent on that ever present competition. The use of competition can aid in building a program and maintaining one once it is built up. The constant exposure is a good recruitment tool to younger children in the area who may not be aware of this type of thing. The remarks from judges can be very beneficial to both students and directors. While at these competitions it allows students to see both good and bad playing among their peers. Often this too can be a good motivator for students to strive to succeed.

I feel that while competition can be a strong motivator but in the long run it is not necessary for musical learning to take place. It is my hope that fifty years down the road students will look back and remember the joys that music brought to them and the fun that they experienced while participating in music not who won grand champion at state their sophomore year. In the end is the stress and struggle really worth a piece of plastic that is going sit on a shelf and collect dust? To me, it is not. My value is on the learning and experiences of music not who is the subjective winner in a contest. I feel that the choice of competition should be partly the student’s decision. If they choose to want to go and compete then they should be prepared for any type of remarks.

Get Better Grades Today

Join and get instant access to over 60,000+ Papers and Essays

Please enter your username and password
Forgot your password?