Read full version essay Pearl Harbor Conspiracy Rebuttle

Pearl Harbor Conspiracy Rebuttle

Print version essay is available for you! You can search Free Term Papers and College Essay Examples written by students!.
Join and get instant access to Pearl Harbor Conspiracy Rebuttle and over 30,000 other Papers and Essays

Category: American History

Autor: anton 20 December 2010

Words: 699 | Pages: 3

Conspiracy theories are all around the modern world covering any topic imaginable ranging from the JFK-Lincoln conspiracy, 9-11, government cover-ups, and even extraterrestrial aliens. It only takes a person with a brain to realize within the first few minutes of reading some of these that they are for the most part unreliable and uneducated opinions. The event of December 7, 1941 is no exception to the norm of conspiracy theories.

The events of Pearl Harbor can undoubtedly be argued as a set-up, but that opinion usually comes from a person with limited knowledge of the government, diplomatic relations, and military protocol. All of the so called “coincidences” are actually smart moves in a time of war.

When Franklin Delano Roosevelt placed an embargo on Japan, he wasn’t doing that in order to put the U.S. in immediate danger, he was realizing that wars have started to become less physical and more economical. A nation cannot continue war efforts without raw materials. Therefore, the quickest way to end aggression is cut off the food supply of the lion. People argue that because of the embargo, we gave Japan no choice but to attack us; however, if the government shared the same opinion on embargos, there would be endless supplies to aggressors and abusers throughout the world.

Military intelligence has not always been known for working together and putting the puzzle pieces together. All the signs for Pearl Harbor are clear now as it is after the event happened, but we can’t understand the fact that in a time of war, there are many signs coming from every direction that they are difficult to put together and complicated to understand. Many people forget that one of the most promising types of warfare used to win is deception. The Japanese, Germans, English, French, Italians, and any other country that was involved in WWII, we can be certain that all of them had sent out false messages intended to trick and confuse opponents. Even the U.S. utilized deception to lure the Japanese fleet to Midway Islands for the Battle of Midway where the Japanese suffered staggering losses. Regarding the concerns of the mini sub sunk by depth charges, operation magic, and all of the other signs, people must remember that there was very little communication between the events. With the mini sub, they wanted conformation because there had been a few false alarms already. How many times can you call “WOLF” before people stop listening, apparently enough to make Pearl Harbor happen.

From a military standpoint, moving the fleet to Hawaii was a very smart idea except for the narrow entrance to the harbor, and the lack of intelligent brass. Pearl Harbor allowed the Pacific Fleet to be more centrally located and much more apt to speedy response to aggression; it’s just that the mouth to the port was just so small. The one thing that could have saved Pearl Harbor was air support but do to “safety concerns” the planes were dealt with in a matter that jeopardized all the lives in the area. Many people believe that concentrating the planes in close formation was a horrible idea, but that’s what they think because they know of what happened at Pearl. Concentrating the planes in the center of the airfield, in times of peace, is a very smart idea as you can set up defenses far enough around that nobody can get close enough to sabotage the planes. In war, the idea is useless as we have learned that the planes were taken out so quickly during the attack.

Pearl Harbor is like so many other conspiracy theories, but like them, they are argued with flimsy facts, opinions, and assumptions. Today’s society may see Pearl Harbor as a conspiracy now, but as a great teacher of mine constantly states, “You cannot judge the actions of yesterday with the morals (or knowledge) of today.” All the signs may have been present in 1941, but they were jumbled, coded, and scattered. As I view Pearl Harbor, it was merely a mistake.

Read Full Essay