Compare And Contrast American Liberalism And Marx's Ideal Of Communism
Essay by 24 • April 1, 2011 • 1,184 Words (5 Pages) • 1,601 Views
Essay Preview: Compare And Contrast American Liberalism And Marx's Ideal Of Communism
American Liberalism and Marx's ideal of Communism are based on two
very different but closely related ideologies. American Liberalism is
based on the ideology of Classical Liberalism or Liberalism. Marx's
ideal of Communism, on the other hand, is based on the Socialism
ideology. Both of these ideologies came to because people didn't agree
with the way thing were being run at that time. After studying them
both closely, because of they way I have been taught in school and at
home that people are selfish, I believe that socialism, as good as it
sounds, could never come to be because of how selfish people are.
Ideology is a word that has many definitions but, in Ball and Dagger
ideology is defined as a fairly coherent and comprehensive set of
ideas that explains and evaluates social conditions, helps people
understand their place in society, and provides a program for social
and political action. These four functions that describe ideology will
set Socialism apart from Classical Liberalism.
Liberalism was a rebellion against religious conformity and ascribed
status of the medieval era. Some people of that time believed that the
church and state should be two different entities instead of being
intertwined with one another. The people wanted religious freedom and
could not do that without change occurring. Ascribed status was also a
major factor contributing to the move to Liberalism. People in the
middle ages were tired of the fact that they could not move up in
society because they had not been born into a noble family. They
decided that people should be able to work to reach a certain status,
or "achieved status". One of the main foundations of liberalism the
encouragement of individual liberty, by any means necessary.
Capitalism is the economic system that is associated with liberalism,
and in this kind of society individuals are free to pursue their own
means of gaining profit without intervention of any sort of
government. Liberalism included having a government, but the
government would be small and have little power that would be used to
protect the people and their rights to freedom.
The idea of socialism has been around for hundreds of years counting
back to the days of Plato (circa 380 B.C.), who constructed Plato's
Republic, an early rendering of the idea of socialism. Years later
another man by the name of Sir Thomas More created his own version of
socialism, More's Utopia, where collective ownership kept a person
from the sins of pride, envy and greed. But the name most associated
with Socialism is Karl Marx, which he said socialism is explained by
the notion "from each according to his ability, to each according to
his need." Marx said that government would be open and all people
would rule together and everything would be publicly owned and shared.
This meant everyone would have the opportunity to become the best they
could be. The economic system associated with Socialism is Communism.
Liberalism and Socialism are two very different ideologies. While
comparing the description of governments a person can that Classical
Liberalists believe that there still should be a small central
government in order to keep the society running smoothly, while
Socialists believe that the society should be run by the people as a
whole and that they should be in control of what happens to them, not
a small group of people. With liberalism people are in control of
their own capital. They can own their own private business and try to
move up in status, while with Socialism everyone is equal and there
are no separate classes or different statuses.
In comparing Socialism and Liberalism one must look at the different
ideologies that represent each economic system. Each ideology performs
the four functions that all ideologies perform and these differences
set them apart. I have grown up in a Liberalist household and as it
is, a liberal society. Growing up in these conditions have instilled
me with the same belief as Classical Liberalists which is that human
beings are typically rational, self-interested, and competitive. I was
taught to do the best I can and be the best at what I do. In comparing
the two ideologies I based my comparison on what I was being taught
while growing up, from all of my teachers, my parents and my peers.
Overall the goal of Classical Liberalists is to maintain individual
liberties or to live as one chooses. The Liberalist ideology says the
explanation
...
...