Affirmative Action

Affirmative action is a plan designed to end discrimination by guaranteeing

minorities will be hired, regardless of race or gender. While our country hires

such groups based upon these guarantees, the qualifications of such people are

occasionally overlooked. Many believe that affirmative action is a very

effective plan; however, the population which opposes such action frequently

includes people of various minorities, as well as many others who have been

wronged by this plan In several cases, this plan causes minorities to be

perceived as being under-qualified when hired; in addition, it also causes a new

minority, the white male. Our government must acknowledge the fact that

affirmative action is not putting an end to discrimination; in all actuality,

this plan has succeeded in creating new minorities, and more reasons for

discrimination. Affirmative action frequently causes qualified employees to be

looked down upon because some believe them to be "affirmative action hires".

Two of my female relatives are currently on the police force; as a result, I

have encountered many discriminatory comments pertaining to their positions.

The first remark I usually receive suggests that they were hired for their

position solely based on gender. Another comment which I usually receive is,

"Well, being a woman probably didn't hurt their resume." Both of my relatives

are very good at their jobs; one was even on the popular television show, Cops.

Neither of them are "wimps", yet most males look down upon them as being hired

because of affirmative action. This type of criticism is received by many

minorities holding good jobs, whether they are qualified or not. To quote

William Reynolds, assistant attorney general in the civil rights division:

In many cases, affirmative action takes away from legitimate

minority success. People look at the black banker

downtown who has made it on his own and say, "He got his

job because of affirmative action." Or, an employer hires a

few talented minority people who would have succeeded

anyway and says, "Those are my affirmative-action hires."

(26)

In this particular case, affirmative action may, or may not, have been the

reason for hiring, yet that is what most perceive. People of any race or gender

should be able to hold a job where their colleagues respect them as equals, not

as "affirmative-action hires".

My cousin, Christine, has also added to my knowledge on how well affirmative

action works at the hospital where she works. One of the administrators

happened to be a black male--who was very qualified for his position--yet most

of the staff accused him of being promoted because of his race. This affected

his morality to such an extent that he resigned shortly after his promotion.

Another black female--who was hired because of her race and gender--is not

qualified for her position, yet is esteemed by her colleagues for her

accomplishments. It seems that minorities are accepted to a certain extent,

until they become someone's boss. It is also a scary situation when a person

has an under-qualified surgeon performing surgery on them because of affirmative

action.

Affirmative action insists that the employer must "[a]void the kind of

unnecessary escalation of criteria for selection and promotion which has

sometimes been used to keep certain classes of people from entering the

mainstream of our economic life" (Berry 19). This aspect of the plan creates

more openings for minorities; however, it also suggests that the standards

should be maintained at a low to guarantee these openings. In my opinion, if

the standards for any position are raised, the productivity and accuracy of the

country will rise accordingly. When the policy of affirmative action is to

almost lower the standards of our society, this sacrifices quality for the sake

of equality. Roy Wilkins, a former Executive Director of the NAACP, stated to

the congress:

Our association has