Animal Rights
Essay by 24 • October 16, 2010 • 1,904 Words (8 Pages) • 1,745 Views
Humans have rights that are either natural rights or earned rights. Natural
rights are rights that every person is born with and keeps throughout his life.
Some of these rights include freedom of speech, the right to an attorney, and
other common sense rights. Some people believe that animals do not have souls;
therefore, they do not have any rights (Regan 104). On the other hand, there
are earned rights like the rights given to hunters. Hunters have the right to
hunt as long as they do not break any laws while doing so. For instance, they
should not hunt out of season or hunt extinct animals. Also, hunters are always
trying to find a new hunting buddy, so they are trying to convert a non-hunter
into a hunter. Everyone wants to get closer to nature in some shape, form, or
fashion. As long as humans do not hunt until an animal becomes extinct, there
is no harm being done (Chepesiuk).
Also, animal owners have rights. They have the right to keep or sell their
animals. If they keep the animals, then the animal will be treated as a pet or
work horse, but if the owner sells the animal, it is usually either slaughtered
or very rarely kept as a pet. "The US government will no longer try to adopt
the thousands of horses that are on public lands. Instead, it will allow horses
to be sent directly to auctions where they can be bought, slaughtered, and then
sold for horse meat" (Chepesiuk). In other words, the government has been
protecting some horses from being slaughtered but is tired of doing so because
it is losing money. On the other hand, some people believe that animals have
the same rights as humans do. Like us, animals can feel pain and fear, but also
excitement and satisfaction" ("Animals are Equal to Humans"). Although there
are many ways to avoid using animals for testing makeup and other things, I
believe that animals do not have the same rights as humans because they are not
in the same species Homo sapiens. Therefore, animals should be used for
testing.
The abuse of animals has greatly increased over the years. "Animals are
crammed into small crates, dragged to auctions with chains, and slaughtered
while they are fully conscious" (Bauston). Some humans do not believe that
animals have rights. On the other hand, "Every living thing has basic rights
and should be treated with respect, regardless of appearance, personality, or
perceived relationship with humans" (Nelson). So, people that are taking part
of the animal rights movement believe that animals have rights just like humans.
"If the inherent value of humans means that they have the right to be treated
with respect, then the same applies to animals" ("Animals are Equal to Humans").
Also, they do not like the idea of animals being hurt in any way. "Because
animals do not have a life after they die, we should do everything in our power
to ensure that this, their only life, is as long and good as possible" (Regan
104). So regardless, animals have rights, but exactly how many rights do they
have?
Animals' rights are different from human rights. Although animals can not
talk, some humans speak up for the rights of animals. These humans are
sometimes known as animal rights activists. Some of these people hold protests
to make their points. People may think that protests never happen, especially
the ones that end up in a brawl. "According to a list compiled by the
Foundation for Biomedical Research, at least 37 demonstrations were planned by
groups in 15 states for World Laboratory Animal Liberation Week" (Holden). "A
new law could send animal rights activists in Britain to jail for up to five
years if they cross the line between peaceful protest and harassment" (Vogel).
Also, according to a statement by the government, illegal protests include those
that are outside of people's homes the cause alarm, harassment, or distress to
the residents (Vogel). They believe that humans mistreat animals even though
animals have human-like rights. Some people believe that "...animal rights...grant
moral standing to only a few creatures. Most of these favored with rights are
birds and mammals, stressing qualities of beauty, intelligence, charisma,
'awareness', or traits that seem human-like" (Nelson). According to Michel de
Montaigne, humans and animals are more closely related to each other than most
people want to think. For instance, rationality is used by both humans and
animals when it comes to making decisions (Carlin). The majority of animals'
rights are "understood" by humans. In other words, they will not exploit the
animals
...
...