Medieval Spain Tolerance Comparison

According to Maria Menocal's Ornament of the World, medieval Spain was a haven from the religious intolerance and dark ages that Europe had succumbed to. When compared to scholarship by Thomas Glick and David Niremburg, the medieval Spain presented in Maria Menocal's Ornament of the World is very narrow and overly positive, as it does not show the intolerance between Jews, Muslims and Christians, the conflict within the religious groups or how the tension increased when Christians gained power from the Muslims.

Rights in Al-Andalus were based on the "dhimmi" principle that Muslims, Christians and Jews were all considered people of the book and thus had religious freedom and peaceful relations were encouraged 1. However, there is evidence of much conflict between these factions with regards to meat markets, money lending, and sexual exploits that often led to hatred or even violence 2. One major source of conflict within the meat markets was due to the dietary restrictions of Jews and Muslims as opposed to those of Christians. Jews and Muslims had similar dietary laws, although animals butchered by Jewish tradition were acceptable to Muslims, those butchered by Muslims did not meet Jewish standards 3. Furthermore, parts of an animal, that could not be eaten by those of the Jewish religion, were sold at discounted prices to Muslims and Christians causing resentment, and even a Papal bull from Pope Benedict XIII stating excommunication for those who purchase meat from Jews 4.

Jews also suffered in their roles of community moneylenders. There was much inter-religious money borrowing, and Jews were often appointed tax collectors and were most associated with usury despite the other faith's use of interest and financing 5. Restrictions were put in place that would not allow Christians to accumulate too much debt, however; there were no such barriers for Muslims and many times money conflicts were dealt with by violence. Property destruction, unlawful imprisonment, as well as murders and beatings of Jewish tax collectors were not uncommon, and both Muslims and Christians were guilty of such acts 6.

All three religions were very harsh to those who copulated outside of their religion. Minority groups feared losing cultural identity an felt they had more to lose by inter-faith relations 7. Muslims chose to purchase legislation from the ruling power of the state as an official procedure to restrict sexual relations. One such piece of legislation requested the death penalty be imposed upon guilty women 8. Some Jewish women in Zaragoza were disfigured for sleeping with a Muslim while a Jewish man was subject to mob justice while visiting a Muslim brothel 9.

Turbulence within the religions was also present with hierarchies dividing those of the same faith against each other. Muslims viewed themselves in three classes: Arabs who had ancestry in the old families of the Arabian world, Berbers who converted during the Arab take over of North Africa, and Neo-Arabs who were Hispano-Romans introduced to Islam in Al-Andalus 10. Arabs were by far the minority, however; but were viewed as the ruling class 11. Berbers were stereotyped as either ignorant herders or brutal soldiers 12. Neo-Muslims were the vast majority in Al-Andalus but occupied the lowest class of Spanish Muslims 13. Even as late as the eleventh century, Neo-Muslims were fighting against constant ethnic slurs, labeled as cowards, chided for their European appearance and thought of as Christian tribesmen 14.

Inter-religious conflict was not exclusive to Muslims. Christians who were Arabized endured harsh criticism. Paul Alvarus, a respected Christian cleric lamented in his The Unmistakable Sign how the young Christians have ignored and despised Christian texts and forgotten their own language in favour of Islamic libraries and Arabic language 15. In the ninth century some Christians became martyrs to protest the vast conversion to Islam many of their peers readily accepted 16. Originally a derogatory name, Mozarabs or wanna-be Arabs eventually became the accepted nomenclature for this new group 17.

Although having the least amount of violent internal disagreements, some Jews turned against their Andalusian culture and wrote texts discrediting their own. Judah Halevi, renowned as the last Andalusian poet of the Golden Age 18, chose to leave his home in Sefarad at age 64 to travel to the now Christian controlled lands of Jerusalem 19. While on his trip Halevi stayed for some time in Alexandria he denounced the philosophical ways of Andalusian Jews as well as the combination of Hebrew with Arabic even going so far as to suggest exile oneself to escape it 20.

During the periods of Christian rule, tensions between the now minorities Muslims and Jews increased. Violence and hostilities escaladed often pitting the two faiths against each other to gain the favour of the ruling Christians 21. A clear example of this conflict is seen in civic processions over which group should have the honour of proceeding first through the streets. While marching through the Muslim quarter, Jews were attacked for having the favoured position in front 22. King John once declared Muslims had the precedence to due their military service but later revoked his decision in favour of the Jewish community for the "greater antiquity of their religion" 23.

Christian ruled courts often acted as a judicial battleground for Muslims and Jews to prove legally, which of the two faiths were the most holy. Much of the controversy was held over conversions. One documented case