Ontology Of Man, Seen By Different Philosophers
Essay by 24 • December 27, 2010 • 1,535 Words (7 Pages) • 1,280 Views
The philosophy of man is an intricate and multidimensional
system involving complex problems rationalized by theoretical ideals.
In writing the Oration on the Dignity of Man, Giovanni Pico della
Mirandola approaches this study universally, wherein, humanism and the
worth and dignity of the populace is affirmed. Saint Augustine's
Confessions attempts to explain the truth and philosophies of man, but
does so with a different approach, referring to man as a product of
society self-consciously misdirected by his soul. These philosophies
share some similarities while also differing from one another; however,
both share a common purpose: to explain the philosophy of man. This
essay will proceed to juxtapose and integrate the works of Giovanni
Pico della Mirandola and St. Augustine taking into consideration the
time periods within which each lived and studied.
Saint Augustine defines the apparent imbalance between what or
who people are and what people truly desire. Desire, according to
Augustine, is accompanied by will, which can misdirect and lead to a dualism of internal and external conflict. This dualism describes the separation that occurs when one is persuaded by social structures to act in a manner that is different from his or her authentic being. His
philosophy is greatly reliant upon religion and is derived from the experience of his sinful youth and conversion to Christianity. Conducting his knowledge through an understanding of original sin - Christians usually refer to this as mankind's first offense, where evil's effects are felt by the entirety of the human race (Christian Classics). Augustine's interpretation, while also incorporating will,
corresponds with the predestined nature to succeed through hardships,
therein, founding man's virtue.
On the other hand, while Pico identifies the importance of a
Christian back round, he approaches this philosophy holistically,
combining natural philosophy and science. In his later studies he marries these ideas to the concept of theology. In this manner, he deviated from what had been the traditional ontological argument to create a new understanding of the relationship between man and religion. He referenced the Ð''chain of being' and alleged that after
God had granted life to creatures he created man who would be grateful of all of his effort and appreciative of the beauty of God's work (wikipedia, Pico). He believed in one's ability to prosper and advance the hierarchical chain through enlightened intellect so that he or she can comprehend the work of God. This idea, although extraordinarily profound for its time period, is evidently what caused the emergence of humanism, thus, birthing social and individual fluidity in said Ð''chain of being'. Furthermore, this then placed the idea of Ð''present day' in the limelight and cast that of Ð''the afterlife' in a secondary role.
Saint Augustine's philosophy focuses on the virtues one received in the afterlife, as opposed to the struggle of a worldly existence. This is not to say that he neglects life on earth, only that his approach is to illustrate that what one does in their lifetime reflects his or her prosperity in the afterlife. Although Saint Augustine was limited in the amount of Knowledge that he was able to obtain, he still managed to define and describe the differences and similarities between free will and self, while identifying a dualism between the body and soul. The explanation of self is crucial in the clarification of his philosophy of man. "Seek for yourself, O man; search for your true self. He who seeks shall find himself in God". Augustine believes that true happiness of the self comes from God, however, because man is free and can therefore exercise Ð''free will' he or she is susceptible to evils impressed by the temptations of the external world. The interaction between body and soul is in conflict when not acting within the practices of God; thus, deepens the struggle as he or she isolates him or herself from the divine. This brings about Saint Augustine's belief that one cannot enhance the status of his or her life, and that a virtuous humanity is the ultimate devotion of god.
Pico Della Mirandola is fortunate in that he is living in an era
that gives him the ability to bridge the past to the future with the
help of Guttenburg and Press. Previously, books were scarce, but the
discovery and establishment of the printing of these books created the
ability for information to be transferred and shared in Europe (History of Printing). This different approach granted an abundance and variety of information and finally allowed these citizens to be able to think and believe in what they chose. What is most important here is that people of demographics, wealth, ethnicity and gender were given access to the same material. One can measure the gradual increase to the citizen's access of knowledge parallel to the rising popularity of
humanism. These opportunities created an accord of optimism. Unlike
Saint Augustine, Pico was able to expand beyond theology simply due to
his access to a greater vat of texts and historical events.
Each philosopher has a varying approach to theology, but both
are based on the belief of Christianity. However, where Augustine
believes in the falling of Adam and Eve (where Adam was the one who
committed the original sin),
...
...